isthismutton?

Translate

Search this blog

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

Couch Critic

Welcome to the first of my monthly posts about films. We are keen film buffs and like to get our hands on the newest titles to watch at home. Finding films we can both watch is a challenge. I don't like shoot-em-ups, most costume dramas, anything with swords / round tables / Jedi / Bruce Willis and J doesn't like sub-titles, real-life dramas/ anything upsetting/ zombies or anything by Lars Von Trier.

Here's this month's top picks.

The Iron Lady
Meryl Streep is normally a bit hit and miss as far as I'm concerned but she hits the spot in this film about Margaret Thatcher, and her BAFTA was well deserved. The film however is a little less successful. I loathed Mrs T and everything she stood for, and in my opinion history will not be kind to her. There was a huge emphasis in the film on her frailty and wandering mind. Maybe it was supposed to counterbalance her ambition and aggression when she was PM, but even I felt it was a bit sad and unnecessary. With the exception of Sir Geoffrey Howe (Anthony Head) it was impossible to tell who any of the cabinet were. I kept wanting them to refer to each other by name. Jim Broadbent didn't make a very realistic Dennis either. He was.....Jim Broadbent. Score: Gail's Gherkins - 5 out of 10.

One Day
J and I watched this at the weekend and were left unimpressed. Based on the David Nicholls' book about a doomed "romance," the film-makers made the mistake of casting an American (to garner the big bucks in the US) as Em. Now when I read the book, Em struck me as being feisty, independent and eccentric in her dress. In the film, Ann Hathaway is first shown with big glasses - the usual device to make an actress look "plain" - and then occasionally in clumpy shoes. But she soon morphs as expected into Ann Hathaway, glossy and limpid eyed.  And her accent! Sometimes she had a go at a northern accent but mostly she sounded like a US actress putting on a posh British accent. At the point the film ended, I was astonished the two characters had even had the time of day for each other. I imagine the director thought the same, because we then had a succession of gooey scenes showing them laughing together and so on, as if to convince us they did have chemistry.
Gail's Gherkins: 4 out of 10.

The Big Year
I hadn't heard of this one or seen anything about it, but it's great fun. Three bird watchers (Owen Wilson, Steve Martin and Jack Black) compete with each other to get the highest number of bird sightings on their "big year." There's nothing new or striking about this film - it's just amiable and warm hearted. Gail's Gherkins: 8 out of 10

I Don't Know How She Does It
Sarah Jessica Parker is the successful career woman and hapless mum in this film based on the novel by Allison Pearson. It starts off with one of the best scenes from the book, Helen "distressing" a bought pie so she can pass it off as home-made at her daughter's school's cake sale. Unfortunately it was one of the highlights of the film. Pierce Brosnan seems uncomfortable in his role as would-be seducer, and I'm sure the film tones down the nature of the flirtation between him and Helen. It's all one-sided in the film, although in the novel I'm sure Helen was flirting back. Christina Hendricks is given a strange role in the film as an occasional narrator. Tepid. Gail's Gherkins: 5 out of 10

After the Waterfall
Air New Zealand offered an eclectric selection of films and I watched this film from New Zealand. It told of the break up of a family after a couple's daughter was abducted near a waterfall. Very bleak but beautifully observed. A pity we don't get to see more films from New Zealand. Gail's Gherkins: 8 out of 10

Friends with Benefits
We enjoyed this - a modern, realistic and contemporary portrayal of a young couple's attempt to be "friends with benefits." There was one snag for me, Justin Timberlake - I just don't find him believable as an actor, but the gorgeous Mila Kunis (left) outweighed that. There are a couple of laugh out loud moments. Gail's Gherkins: 7 out of 10

4 comments:

Anne @ The Frump Factor said...

Yeah, you don't want to get me started on the "putting big glasses on a gorgeous starlet" thing. Ugh, that Ann Hathaway film looked just awful. I do look forward to seeing Meryl Streep's performance, though I share your ambivalence about being asked to empathize with the real-life woman. I can't stop myself from putting in a plug for "The Artist" -- it does break your "no subtitles" rule, but there is very little text, it's large, and I thought the film was just delightful! Thanks for "vetting" these films for us.

Duchess of Tea said...

Hello my darling,

I popped in to wish you a day filled with love and to let you know I truly appreciate all those lovely words you left for me while I was away.

Love & Hugs
Duchess

Allyson said...

First of all...I've been away awhile and you've exchanged boobs for ketchup. And I still love it!! Very witty.

Second: I've always wondered what the British think about American actors portraying British accents. I remember when I directed "The Secret Garden" as a senior in high school what a witch I was about the actors getting it right. But sometimes I think that, compared to actual British actors like Colin Firth and Kate Winslet, they just sound...like they're trying too hard.

Third: I've never head of The Big Year but now I'm adding it to my list. And I was so eager beaver to see The Iron Lady but perhaps I'll just wait for it to show up on Netflix. I was wondering, though, how you felt about The King's Speech. I just watched it last weekend (I know...I think the last time I actually went to the movie theater was 2004) and I really loved it. But maybe the British not so much?

Gail said...

I thought The King's Speech was good; I wasn't so crazy about it that I would buy it to add to our library. I was a little surprised it got so many awards. I love Colin Firth, Geoffrey Rush and Helena BC, so expected to love it more. But perhaps it seemed a bit over hyped. Some US actors get it right with the British accent --- Renee Zellweger's very posh accent in Bridget Jones was great, just right for the role.

Gadget

This content isn't available over encrypted connections yet.